Gerber Baby Rice Cereal or BeachNut Baby Rice Cereal



Probably the most confusing time for new parents is the time of introduction of solids to their baby’s diet. Where to start? What to buy? How to serve? Adding to that confusion is the multiple choices of baby products available in the grocery stores and online. Pediatricians recommend to start from baby rice cereal mixed with formula or breast milk. Here the confusion kicks in again. Which baby rice cereal to buy? Is Gerber baby rice cereal better than Beechnut baby rice cereal? What is the difference between them if any? In this baby cereal review we compare Gerber rice cereal with Beechnut rice cereal in order to help you answer some of these questions. Based on the input from many moms we review the texture, taste, ingredients and convenience factors in our review.
Each category is assigned evaluation number in the scale from 1 to 5, 5 being the best and 1 the worst.
Texture
Both Gerber and Beechnut rice cereals for baby resemble potato flakes and look very paper-like processed food. Gerber cereal is more flaky than Beechnut cereal. Both are quick dissolving dry flakes for the convenience of busy moms: all you have to do is to pour some cereal into the bowl, add some formula or breast milk to it, mix and serve. Now, how much of that cereal and how much of liquid to pour might be confusing at the beginning. If it is your baby’s first solids eating experience, mix one tablespoon of rice cereal with 4 tablespoons of formula or breast milk. Rice cereal will become very runny. Since your baby is not used to solids, this liquid texture if perfect, closely resembling liquids that your baby has been consuming so far. Gerber rice cereal is easy to mix and in seconds becomes smooth and ready to feed. Some of moms, however, point out that Beechnut rice cereal is harder to mix and often forms lumps. One of the reasons for lumpiness might be the age of cereal. If you store an open box of Beechnut cereal for more than a month it might become harder to mix and lumpy. Once mixed with breast milk, formula or water, Gerber cereal stays longer of the same texture than Beechnut rice cereal. It has been observed my many moms that Beechnut rice cereal becomes very runny if it is not given to the baby right away.
Bottom line: Gerber rice cereal's texture is 5 Beechnut rice cereal's texture 1
Taste
The taste of the rice cereal is well defined by the word tasteless. Some moms described the taste as paper-like. What adds taste to the rice cereal is the liquid you mix it with. If you mix your baby’s cereal with formula, it will taste as good as your baby’s formula. If you mix it with sweet tasting breast milk, then it will taste good. If you mix it with plain water, the taste of cereal will be blank. However, some moms observed that Gerber rice cereal’s taste is somewhat more pleasant than Beechnut rice cereal’s taste. The difference, however is questionable.
Bottom line: Gerber rice cereal's taste is 3 Beechnut rice cereal's taste is 2.5
Ingredients
What goes into making a baby rice cereal is important. Baby’s first solid food should be nutritious, easy to digest and without unwanted artificial or allergenic ingredients. Here is where many parents had something positive to say about Beechnut rice cereal. Beechnut rice cereal does not have soy products in it. This is very important if your baby has allergies to soy. Gerber baby rice cereal, however contains soy products. Gerber and Beechnut rice cereals also contains mixed tocopherols, which are products of vitamin E that contain alpha, beta, delta, and gamma forms of tocopherol. Beechnut cereal has added vitamin D3 and Gerber rice cereal does not have it. D vitamin deficiency in young infants can cause rickets, which results in skeletal deformities. Exclusively breastfed babies are more at risk than formula fed babies. Thus it is nice that Beechnut rice cereal has added vitamin D. Here is a list of ingredients of both rice cereals:
Beechnut rice cerealRice flour, sunflower lecithin, vitamins and minerals: tricalcium phosphate, electrolytic iron, dicalcium phosphate, zinc sulfate, d-alpha-tocopheryl acetate (vitamin E), mixed tocopherols, niacinamide, calcium d-pantothenate, thiamine mononitrate (vitamin B1), riboflavin (vitamin B2), pyridoxine hydrochloride (vitamin B6), vitamin B12, folic acid, vitamin D3.
Gerber rice cerealRice flour, tri- and dicalcium phosphate, soybean oil, soy lecithin, mixed tocopherols (to preserve freshness), electrolytic iron, zinc sulfate, alpha-tocopheryl acetate (vitamin E), niacinamide (a B vitamin), pyridoxine hydrochloride (vitamin B6), riboflavin (vitamin B2), thiamine mononitrate (vitamin B1), folic acid (a B vitamin), vitamin B12 (cyanocobalamin).
Bottom line: Gerber r.c.ingredients is 3 Beechnut r.c. ingredients is 5
Convenience Factor
For most of parents with babies every minute during the day is precious and every penny counts, so the convenience factor takes into account the price of baby rice cereal as well as how easy it is to prepare and serve. Parents noticed that Beechnut rice cereal for babies is cheaper than Gerber rice cereal, so moms who are looking to save a few cents here and there buy Beechnut. When it comes to the packaging, we have mixed opinions. Some moms praise Beechnut for its easy pour box with a spout, while others claim Gerber’s box is much less messy. Either way, both Gerber and Beechnut get some complains from busy moms that their rice cereal packaging needs improvement. Finally, Gerber rice cereal is a clear winner when it comes to adding liquid and mixing it into a smooth puree. Moms complain that Beechnut cereal is hard to mix, gets lumpy and gets very watery quite fast after 10 minutes or so.
Bottom line: Gerber r.c. convenience is 4 Beechnut r.c. convenience is 4
In retrospect, whichever baby rice cereal you choose, Gerber or Beechnut’s, both are well trusted brands having quality of the food as a top priority. It all depends on you now, which factors are the most important to you. The overall rating is higher for Gerber rice cereal, but if you take into account individual factors, you might prefer Beechnut cereal over Gerber. Your baby is also a good judge of a product, so whisk up a bowl of rice ceral from both brands and see which one your baby likes more! The preferences are unpredictable!














